| Jack Abraham, University of Northern Colorado | 2026 | Golf |
| José Acuna, Rice University | 2020 | Cross Country |
| Darius Alberty, Southern Illinois University Edwardsville | 2025 | Track & Field |
| Julian Alemany, Scottsdale Community College | 2021 | Baseball |
| Nate Anderson, University of Washington | 2019 | Golf |
| Anderson Baker, Fordham University | 2022 | Track and Field |
| Jaxson Baker, University of Central Arkansas | 2018 | Basketball |
| Taub Baldyga, Mercer University | 2025 | Lacrosse |
| Race Bates, University of Notre Dame | 2024 | Rugby |
| Nathan Benzie, University of San Diego | 2025 | Football |
| Mateo Berastegui, Fort Lewis College | 2026 | Golf |
| Tanner Bice, Wofford College | 2026 | Track & Field |
| Haaris Bjotvedt, Lehigh University | 2017 | Crew |
| Xander Black, University of Michigan | 2021 | Cross Country |
| Jack Blake, University of Alabama | 2017 | Swimming |
| Dylan Boenning, Washington State University | 2025 | Golf |
| Carson Borges, Regis University | 2024 | Baseball |
| Brayden Bozak, UNLV/Denver | 2022 | Golf |
| Pierce Braun, Grand Canyon University/Hawaii | 2020 | Golf |
| Jordan Briggs, Lake Forest College | 2017 | Football |
| Hastings Brislin, Tufts University | 2025 | Soccer |
| Elisha Brooks, University of South Carolina | 2019 | Track |
| Jack Warner Brown, U.S. Air Force Academy | 2022 | Tennis |
| John "Jack" Brown, Davidson College | 2022 | Soccer |
| Ryan Burbach, Cornell University | 2025 | Basketball |
| Noah Burdick, Hofstra University | 2024 | Lacrosse |
| Ian Burke, Portland State University | 2018 | Basketball |
| Drew Burns, Santa Clara University | 2018 | Cross Country |
| Luke Burns, University of Virginia | 2024 | Soccer |
| Josh Buse, Queens (N.C.) University | 2025 | Lacrosse |
| Christian Camarata, University of Chicago | 2025 | Football |
| Jackson Camarata, Washington University | 2021 | Football |
| Jon Carr, Princeton University | 2017 | Crew |
| Luca Cannizzo, Grand Canyon University | 2024 | Track & Field |
| Chaz Carson, University of Chicago | 2024 | Football |
| Johnny Casale, Loyola Marymount | 2024 | Baseball |
Jonah Castle, St. Mary’s College | 2026 | Baseball |
| Victor Castillo, University of Arizona | 2018 | Rugby |
| Henry Chabot, Chapman University | 2022 | Baseball |
Harrison Chambers, Colorado Mesa University | 2026 | Football |
| Patrick Chew, Murray State University | 2022 | Basketball |
| Andrew Chong, Williams College | 2021 | Tennis |
| Carter Clemmensen, UC Santa Barbara | 2018 | Soccer |
| Sean Cooper, Cochise College | 2019 | Baseball |
| Willie Cornejo-Farmer, Loyola Marymount/Cisco College | 2024 | Baseball |
| Jorden Cunningham, Washington State | 2025 | Football |
| Henry Dall, University of San Diego | 2024 | Golf |
| James DeCremer, Oregon State/Arkansas | 2022 | Baseball |
Ben DeSpong, University of Alabama, Birmingham | 2026 | Soccer |
| Will DeSpong, Track & Field, U.S. Naval Academy | 2025 | Track & Field |
| Michael Diaz, Santa Clara University/ Grand Canyon | 2020 | Baseball |
| Dan DiMaria, Grand Canyon University | 2022 | Rugby |
| Erik DiMaria, Northern Arizona University | 2018 | Football |
| Carlos Dominguez, Ottawa University | 2022 | Football |
| Jackson Douglas, Kenyon College | 2024 | Swimming |
| Finn Dowdall, Princeton University | 2021 | Swimming & Diving |
| Johnny Dowse, University of San Diego | 2019 | Baseball |
| Jack Dozer, University of Denver | 2022 | Golf |
| Gage DuBois, University of Arizona | 2022 | Swimming |
| Layton Duncan, University of Colorado-Pueblo/Lake Forest | 2023 | Football |
| Conor Dunn, University of California Santa Barbara | 2018 | Volleyball |
| Andrew Duque, Benedictine College (Kansas) | 2020 | Track |
| Drew Dyer, Chicago State University/Carthage College | 2018 | Baseball |
| Billy Eastep, Yale University | 2024 | Football |
| Andre Eden, Bowdoin University | 2020 | Football |
Carsten Ellingson, Concordia University (Wisc.) | 2026 | Volleyball |
| DaMarcus Ellis, New Mexico State | 2021 | Football |
| Josiah Estrella, South Mountain CC | 2021 | Baseball |
| Hayden Everson, Gonzaga University | 2022 | Crew |
| Charlie Fallon, Washington University | 2021 | Cross Country |
| Ryan Fesperman, Sacramento State | 2026 | Baseball |
| Josh Finch-Logan, Western New Mexico University | 2026 | Football |
| Devin Fitzgerald, University of Notre Dame | 2026 | Football |
| Luca Flamino, University of San Diego | 2025 | Rowing |
| Samuel Fletcher, UC Santa Barbara | 2018 | Soccer |
| Connor Forsythe, Lake Forest University | 2020 | Football |
| A.J. Frakes, Fordham University | 2018 | Swimming |
Eli Friedman, Marquette University | 2026 | Lacrosse |
| Sean Gage, University of Nevada | 2017 | Swimming |
| Jackson Garcia, University of San Diego | 2019 | Football |
| Malaki Garnica, Glendale CC | 2025 | Basketball |
| Luis Gastelum, Adams State | 2023 | Football |
| Ben Geist, Oberlin College | 2025 | Lacrosse |
| Evan Giesecke, Bates (Maine) College | 2025 | XC/TF |
| Joe Gilligan, University of Michigan | 2019 | Crew |
| Noah Gonzales, Lake Forest College | 2018 | Football |
| Marcos Gonzalez, Creighton University | 2020 | Cross Country |
| Rex Goossen, UNLV | 2017 | Football |
| Cameron Grams, Arizona State University | 2017 | Hockey |
| Joey Grams, Arizona State University | 2017 | Hockey |
| Caleb Greenfield, Illinois Wesleyan | 2022 | Lacrosse |
| Lucas Grennan, University of Colorado Colorado Spring s | 2018 | Baseball |
| Patrick Grindey, Creighton University | 2020 | Rugby |
| Michael Grindey, Concordia (Neb.) University | 2018 | Football |
| Declan Groesbeck, Rose Hulman Institute | 2022 | Track and Field |
| Matt Graff, Paradise Valley CC | 2021 | Baseball |
| Deric Hall, United States Air Force Academy | 2019 | Soccer |
| E.J. Hamilton, Black Hills State University | 2019 | Football |
Hale Hansen, Montana State University | 2026 | Basketball |
| Brody Harr, Vanderbilt University | 2022 | Cross Country |
| Kyle Harrison, Georgetown University | 2018 | Crew |
| Joe Hart, University of San Diego | 2018 | Crew |
| Cade Hawkins, Cornell University | 2017 | Crew |
| Charlie Hazen, Tufts University | 2024 | Baseball |
Mark Heffern, Southern Methodist University | 2026 | Swimming |
Dane Helt, Lacrosse, Iona University | 2026 | Lacrosse |
| Tony Hendricks, UCLA | 2019 | Golf |
| Matt Hernandez, Macalester (Minn.) College | 2025 | Football |
| Anekin Hetman, New Mexico State University | 2019 | Track, Cross Country |
| Benton Hickman, University of Arizona | 2025 | Baseball |
| Anthony Hidalgo, Phoenix College/Gonzaga | 2020 | Soccer |
| Kai Hogan, Glendale Community College | 2025 | Basketball |
Isaac Holder, Gonzaga University | 2026 | Baseball |
| Michael Horne, Baseball, Tufts University | 2025 | Baseball |
| Noah Hubbard, Claremont-McKenna | 2025 | Football |
| Robert Huerta, Arizona State University | 2020 | Rugby |
| Parker Hughes, University of Michigan | 2019 | Swimming |
| Taj Hughes, Drake University/Northern Iowa | 2022 | Football |
| Nassim Isaac, Northern Arizona University | 2025 | Football |
| Deion James, Hampton University | 2024 | Lacrosse |
Joseph Jarrett-Torres, Adams State University | 2026 | Swimming |
Ashton Joswiak, University of Wisconsin | 2026 | Swimming |
| Thomas Joswiak, University of Missouri-Columbia | 2022 | Swimming & Diving |
| Xavier Juniel, Mesa CC/Riverside CC | 2018 | Football |
| Carter Kappes, Chapman University | 2024 | Soccer |
| Cameron Kaiser, Santa Clara University | 2021 | Golf |
| Declan Kelly, Arizona Christian University | 2025 | Soccer |
| Joey Kelly, Syracuse University | 2019 | Football |
| Matthew Kempton, Northern Arizona University | 2017 | Football |
| Devan Kennedy, University of Iowa | 2024 | Football |
| Sean Kennedy, U.S. Naval Academy | 2024 | Wrestling |
| Mustafa Khaled, University of Arizona | 2020 | Rugby |
| Trevor Klein, Carroll College | 2020 | Football |
| Mason Kokodynski, Loyola Marymount University | 2019 | Baseball |
| Anderson Kopp, University of Kansas | 2025 | Football |
Deshawn Krein, Montana State University | 2026 | Football |
| Dylan Krueger, Claremont McKenna College | 2020 | Swimming |
| Justin Krueger, Emerson College | 2022 | Swimming & Diving |
| Brandon Krupp, Bowdoin College | 2018 | Football |
| Jack Lafflam, University of Arizona | 2025 | Baseball |
| Hociel Landa, Rice University | 2017 | XC/Track |
Nico Lara, Glendale Community College | 2026 | Baseball |
| Connor Leber, Cal Poly/Washington | 2020 | Soccer |
| Matthew Leonard, Lake Forest College | 2017 | Football |
| Nolan Lopez, Santa Clara University | 2021 | Baseball |
| Marcus Lye, Northern Arizona University/Massacusetts | 2022 | Football |
| Cole Macias, Arizona State University | 2018 | Rugby |
| Trey Markham, Gaston College/Western Arizona/Park | 2024 | Baseball |
| Luke Mason, Gonzaga University | 2017 | XC/Track |
| Connor McCabe, Northwestern University | 2018 | Soccer |
Owen McGuire, U.S. Air Force Academy | 2026 | Baseball |
| Brennen McHenry, University of Texas/Arizona State | 2024 | Track |
| Charlie McGinnis, Hofstra University | 2024 | Lacrosse |
| Thomas McGrath, McKendree University | 2017 | Volleyball |
| Jack Meissner, UC Santa Barbara/South Mountain/Seattle | 2024 | Baseball |
| Brayden Michael, Black Hills State University | 2025 | Football |
| Andrew Milek, University of Southern California | 2020 | Football |
| Laird Miller, Rollins College | 2024 | Laacrosse |
| Mateja Milovanovic, University of Arizona | 2020 | Swimming |
| Josh Minton, University of Chicago | 2022 | Football |
| Zack Missigman, St. Mary's College | 2020 | Golf |
| Dominic Mitchell, Kansas State University | 2025 | Football |
| Francesco "Case" Montanile, University of California Irvine | 2020 | Soccer |
| Caleb Moore, Lake Forest College | 2017 | Football |
| Jackson Moran, Rice University | 2021 | Cross Country |
| Ben Morrison, University of Notre Dame | 2022 | Football |
| Garrett Munk, St. Louis University | 2020 | Swimming |
Josh Murar, Gonzaga University | 2026 | Rowing |
| John Murphy, Regis University | 2022 | Track & Field |
| Colby Muselmann, Central Washington University | 2020 | Baseball |
| Conner Nagaki, Queens College | 2017 | Volleyball |
| Miles Nash, Illinois Wesleyan | 2022 | Basketball |
| Myles Newbie, Colorado Mesa University | 2021 | Football |
| Kellen Newsome, Northwest Nazarene University | 2022 | Baseball |
| Matt Nickerson, University of Arizona | 2020 | Rugby |
Jack Nidiffer, Fairfield University | 2026 | Rowing |
| Teddy Nielson, University of Arizona | 2024 | Swimming |
| Mike Niezgodski, Texas Christian University | 2018 | Swimming |
Vinny Noble, Trinity University | 2026 | Baseball |
| Noah Nuez, U.S. Naval Academy | 2022 | Golf |
| Nero Nuez, U.S. Naval Academy | 2025 | Track & Field |
Ronan O’Brien, Columbia University | 2026 | Baseball |
| Coleman O’Donnell, Case Western | 2025 | Baseball |
J.P. Odden, Phoenix College | 2026 | Soccer |
| Luke Odden, Wabach Valley JC/Ga. Southern | 2021 | Baseball |
| Jack Ohman, Yale University | 2024 | Baseball |
| Connor Oldani, Grand Canyon/BYU | 2024 | Volleyball |
| Ian O'Riley, Harvard University | 2024 | Rowing |
| Adone Panatonni, Gettysburg College | 2026 | Baseball |
| Christian Parenza, Lake Forest College | 2025 | Football |
Ryan Peitzmeier, University of Utah | 2026 | Lacrosse |
James Pike, University of Arizona | 2026 | Football |
| Noah Pittenger, University of Arizona | 2017 | Football |
| Logan Powell, University of Wisconsin | 2025 | Football |
| Tyler Powell, University of Arizona | 2022 | Football |
| Michael Quartermain, Amherst College | 2022 | Football |
| Cole Rassas, U.S. Air Force Academy | 2022 | Lacrosse |
| Owen Reinhart, Washington University (St. Louis) | 2020 | Football |
| Ross Reiter, Colorado State | 2018 | Football |
| Nik Rodriguez, George Fox University | 2024 | Football |
| Simon Root, Detroit Mercy | 2025 | Track & Field |
| Mardale Rowe, Fordham University | 2024 | Football |
| Aidan Rowland, George Washington University | 2019 | Crew |
| Che Rubalcava, Northwestern Oklahoma University | 2019 | Baseball |
| George Rubelsky, Columbia University | 2022 | Golf |
| Anthony Runfola, Haverford College | 2021 | Baseball |
| Jack Ryan, Point Loma Nazarene | 2024 | Baseball |
| Kharlo Sandez, Tech de Monterrey | 2024 | Football |
| Nick Sanford, University of New Hampshire | 2024 | Basketball |
| Carson Scarbrough, Rockhurst University | 2025 | Track & Field |
| Masen Schechterle, Queens University | 2021 | Baseball |
| Patrick Schramm, University of Utah | 2018 | Swimming |
| Max Schwarz, Emory University | 2018 | Golf |
| Tobin Shanks, Southern Methodist University | 2018 | Soccer |
| Daylen Sharper, Stanford University | 2026 | Football |
| Sully Shannon, University of Idaho | 2019 | Football |
| Joey Slaybaugh, Loyola Marymount University | 2022 | Crew |
| Marco Smith, Biola University | 2024 | Trak & Field |
| George Smith, Regis University | 2024 | Baseball |
| Braeden Speed, Loyola Maryland/Florida Atlantic | 2024 | Basketball |
| Jack Sorenson, College of the Holy Cross | 2022 | Swimming & Diving |
| Tyler Spielman, Auburn University | 2024 | Golf |
| Zac Swanson, University of Texas | 2022 | Football |
Blake Sweetman, Benedictine (Kansas) College | 2026 | Football |
| David Sweetman, Bethany College | 2023 | Football |
| Jackson Sweetman, Benedictine College | 2025 | Wrestling |
Noah Swetlishoff, Franklin and Marshall College | 2026 | Swimming |
| Greyson Taylor, Arizona State/Grand Canyon | 2019 | Track & Field |
| Ryan Teetsel, Georgetown University | 2017 | Crew |
| Rexx Tessler, University of Arizona | 2017 | Football |
| Cree Thomas, Notre Dame/Colorado | 2025 | Football |
| Nate Thompson, Princeton University | 2018 | Volleyball |
| Nick Thompson, Miami University (Ohio) | 2019 | Hockey |
| Atilla Toth, Air Force Academy | 2024 | Soccer |
| Ty Trickle, Trinity College | 2024 | Wrestling |
| Tommy Trudeau, University of Colorado Colorado Springs | 2018 | Baseball |
Case Vanden Bosch, U.S. Air Force Academy | 2026 | Football |
| Regis Velez, Northern Arizona University | 2020 | Football |
| Duncan Viscom, South Dakota | 2024 | Football |
| Erik Volfson, Lafayette College | 2024 | Lacrosse |
| Augie Walters, College of Holy Cross | 2021 | Baseball |
| Max Ware, Arizona State University /Stoneybrook | 2022 | Football |
| E.J. Warner, Temple University/Rice/Fresno State | 2022 | Football |
| Andrew Werner, Princeton University | 2022 | Volleyball |
| John Waters, University of Redlands | 2018 | Football |
CJ Wendell, Milwaukee School of Engineering | 2026 | Football |
| Xander Welty, University of Richmond | 2021 | Lacrosse |
| Marques White, Dartmouth University/SMU | 2019 | Football |
| Luke Whitlow, Scottsdale Community College | 2022 | Baseball |
| Luke Wieskamp, Menlo College/Northern Arizona | 2025 | Basketball |
Brandon Wirtz, Iowa Western CC | 2026 | Baseball |
Amaru Williams, West Nottingham Academy | 2026 | Williams |
| Noah Williams, Stanford University | 2017 | Football |
| Matthew Winter, Western New Mexico State | 2020 | Football |
| Zander Wondrash, Simpson College | 2019 | Football |
| Will Worthington, University of San Diego | 2019 | Baseball |
| Harrison Yu, Colorado College | 2025 | Lacrosse |
| Colin Zimmerman, Massachusetts Institute of Technology | 2025 | Volleyball |
